Extra Story Outfits, for the purposes of this wiki, cover extra outfits and shoes that were made available for the first six Historical Characters, and often had ties to the stories or additional playsets.
At least one outfit was seen in only one story (often the meet or winter story); the other was often seen frequently as a play or work outfit (as they are from times when a child would keep separate clothes for chores or play, so as not to muss their better day to-day clothes in times when laundry was not convenient). Felicity's riding breeches are not technically either; however, Benjamin Davidson's breeches are a major item in Meet Felicity and so are being listed here.
All but one outfit is retired.
- Felicity Merriman: Felicity's Work Gown, Riding Habit and Hat, Riding Breeches and Hat
- Josefina Montoya: Party Dress and Spencer Jacket
- Kirsten Larson: Swedish Dirndl and Kerchief, Kirsten's Work Dress, Two-Tone Boots
- Addy Walker: Patriotic Party Dress, Addy's Work Dress and Apron, Addy's Work Shoes
- Samantha Parkington: Play Dress and Pinafore, Tea Dress, White Party Slippers
- Molly McIntire: Halloween Hula Costume, After-School Outfit, Classic Brown Oxfords