Originally, each character had a single pet or animal that was mentioned at some point in their birthday stories with the notable exception of Samantha Parkington, who was instead given a stuffed bear (though Jip was part of her birthday story). Later, other characters were given additional pets that were part of their stories in a more prominent manner than the birthday story animal. Several of the pets did not belong solely to the character they are associated with.
List of Dolls' Pets
- This list contains all the pets and animals in a character's collection.
- Kaya'aton'my: Tatlo; Steps High; Sparks Flying; Kaya's Animals
- Felicity Merriman: Posie the Lamb; Penny; Patriot the Foal
- Caroline Abbott: Inkpot, Garnet
- Josefina Montoya: Sombrita
- Cécile Rey: Cochon, Cécile's Parrot
- Marie-Grace Gardner: Argos
- Kirsten Larson: Mama Cat and Kitten
- Addy Walker: Sunny
- Samantha Parkington: Jip
- Rebecca Rubin: Rebecca's Kittens
- Kit Kittredge: Grace the Basset Hound
- Molly McIntire: Bennett the Dog
- ↑ Originally released as "American Girl Horse"
- ↑ Garnet does not belong to Caroline; she belongs to Lydia Livingston.
- ↑ The cats are not Kirsten's personal pets.
- ↑ Sunny does not belong to Addy; he belongs to M'dear.
- ↑ Jip does not belong to Samantha; he belongs to Cornelia.
- ↑ The kittens belong to Leonardo Rossi.